If those lovely leather Aldo sandals don't fit, here are some others from their site (that come in size 11!) that I've been considering...
Pavelka, $50 (might be $34.98 on sale?)
Tromp, $34.98 on sale
Not all are available in-store in Charlottetown, but can order all online (free shipping on orders over $100) and will likely check with the store to see if they can be returned if they don't fit properly... Decisions, decisions.